Elbow macaroni in a béchamel made with whole milk and butter, then loaded with sharp cheddar for flavor, Gruyère for nuttiness, Monterey Jack for melt and Parmesan for salt and bite, baked under a crisp panko and Parmesan crust. This is the full version, with no cottage cheese or vegetables blended into the sauce. We undercook the pasta by 2 minutes so it drinks up sauce in the oven instead of turning soft.
A sixth of the dish, about 1½ cups, is one serving; the recipe makes six. You need a large pot for the pasta, a 3-quart saucepan for the sauce and a 9 by 13-inch baking dish. Buy the cheeses in blocks and shred them yourself: pre-shredded cheese has anti-caking starch that makes the sauce grainy. Let it rest 10 minutes after baking so it sets enough to scoop.
Why this one works
Four cheeses at a stated weight each, 18 oz in all, supply 23 g of the 38 g protein per serving; the macaroni adds 10 g.
A roux of 4 tbsp butter and ¼ cup flour lets the sauce hold that much cheese without splitting or turning oily; it adds about 85 kcal a serving.
The sauce gets 1 tsp salt for six servings, about 390 mg sodium each, because the cheeses bring 600 mg; a serving comes to 1,060 mg sodium.
It reheats in portions for 4 days at $2.51 a serving, and the topping crisps again in the oven.
Ingredient notes
Elbow macaroni (1 lb / 454 g). Classic elbows, or cavatappi or shells at the same weight. Cook 2 minutes less than the package says. Whole milk (3 cups / 720 ml). Gives the sauce its body. Warming it first lets it whisk into the roux without lumps. The swaps table shows the change with reduced-fat milk. The four cheeses (sharp cheddar 8 oz / 226 g; Gruyère, Monterey Jack 4 oz / 113 g each; Parmesan 2 oz / 56 g). Use an aged sharp cheddar, orange or white. Gruyère is the most expensive of the four; more cheddar in its place saves $0.63 a serving. Swiss can stand in too. Most Gruyère and Parmesan are made with animal rennet, so they aren't vegetarian. Look for ones labeled vegetarian (made with microbial rennet). Dry mustard (1 tsp / 2.5 g). Ground mustard powder. It sharpens the cheese flavor without tasting of mustard.
Scales every quantity and the servings count. The panel stays per serving.
Salt for the pasta water, optional
1 lb(454 g) elbow macaroni
4 tbsp(56 g) unsalted butter
¼ cup(32 g) all-purpose flour
3 cups(720 ml) whole milk, warmed
1 tsp(2.5 g) dry mustard
½ tsp(1.2 g) smoked paprika
¼ tsp(0.5 g) ground nutmeg
1 tsp(6 g) fine salt
½ tsp(1 g) black pepper
8 oz(226 g) sharp cheddar, shredded
4 oz(113 g) Gruyère, shredded
4 oz(113 g) Monterey Jack, shredded
2 oz(56 g) Parmesan, finely grated, divided
½ cup(30 g) panko
1 tbsp(14 g) unsalted butter, melted, for the topping
Method
Heat the oven to 375 °F (190 °C) with a rack in the center.
Boil the macaroni in a large pot of water, salted if you like, 2 minutes short of the package time. Drain and set aside.
Melt 4 tbsp butter in a 3-quart saucepan over medium. Whisk in the flour and cook 2 minutes, whisking, until it smells nutty but has not browned.
Pour in the warm milk in a slow stream, whisking constantly. Simmer 5 to 6 minutes, whisking, until it coats a spoon.
Take the pan off the heat. Whisk in the mustard, paprika, nutmeg, salt and pepper.
Add the cheddar, Gruyère, Jack and half the Parmesan a handful at a time, stirring until each melts before adding the next.
Fold in the macaroni and scrape it into a 9 by 13-inch baking dish.
Toss the panko with the remaining Parmesan and the melted butter and scatter it evenly over the top.
Bake 20 to 25 minutes, until bubbling at the edges and the top is deep golden.
Rest 10 minutes before cutting into 6 portions.
Cook’s note
Taking the sauce off the heat before the cheese goes in is what keeps it smooth; cheese stirred into a simmering sauce tightens, squeezes out its fat and turns stringy and grainy.
Storage
Refrigerate 4 days in portions. Reheat covered at 350 °F (175 °C) for 20 minutes with a splash of milk, uncovering for the last 5, or microwave 2 minutes with a spoonful of milk stirred in. Freezes 2 months; the sauce turns slightly grainy after thawing.
Nutrition
Nutrition Facts
6 servings per recipeServing size 1 of 6 servings
Calories per serving820
% Daily Value*
Total Fat 42g
54%
Saturated Fat 24g
120%
Sodium 1,060mg
46%
Total Carbohydrate 72g
26%
Dietary Fiber 3g
11%
Total Sugars 9g
Protein 38g
76%
* The % Daily Value tells you how much a nutrient in a serving of food contributes to a daily diet. 2,000 calories a day is used for general nutrition advice.
How this panel was built
Every ingredient in this recipe is mapped to a USDA FoodData Central entry and the panel is computed from those entries for one serving as written. Optional ingredients and anything "to taste" are excluded. Values are rounded: protein to the gram, calories to the nearest 5 and sodium to the nearest 10 mg. The panel is calculated, not lab-tested; a different brand of stock or cheese will move sodium and fat. Cost per serving is an estimate at national-average store-brand prices; your store will differ.