Tuna Melt on Rye with Greek Yogurt

A griddled tuna melt on seeded rye, the tuna salad bound with Greek yogurt and Dijon: 43 g protein and 455 calories.

Protein / serving43g
Calories455
Total time30min
Serves4
Fiber5g
Cost (est.)$2.86/srv
Tuna Melt on Rye with Greek Yogurt: one griddled sandwich, cut on the diagonal with one half leaning on the other to show the cut face

A diner-style tuna melt griddled in a skillet: tuna salad bound with Greek yogurt and Dijon instead of mayonnaise, a slice of tomato, sharp cheddar on both sides of the filling, and seeded rye buttered thin on the outside and cooked until deep golden. The yogurt gives the salad the same creamy hold mayonnaise does and a little more tang, which the pickle, dill and lemon build on.

Thirty minutes in a 12-inch skillet with a lid, two sandwiches at a time. Buy chunk light tuna packed in water with no salt added; it is milder than albacore and holds together in larger flakes. A lid over the pan for the first side melts the cheese before the rye scorches. Seeded rye with caraway is the classic.

Why this one works
  • A full can of tuna goes into each sandwich, which is where most of the protein comes from: 29 g of the 43 g.
  • Greek yogurt replaces the mayonnaise in the tuna salad; the same ½ cup of mayonnaise would mean 170 kcal more and 21 g more fat per sandwich.
  • The tuna is the no-salt-added kind and nothing else is salted, so the pickle and cheese season it: 760 mg sodium per sandwich, about 390 mg of it from the rye.
  • One teaspoon of butter per sandwich, spread on the outside, browns the rye and adds 35 kcal and 4 g fat.

Ingredient notes

Ingredients for Tuna Melt on Rye with Greek Yogurt: 2% Greek yogurt, celery stalks, red onion, dill pickle, Dijon mustard, lemon juice, chopped fresh dill, seeded rye bread, unsalted butter, sharp cheddar, tomato

Low-sodium chunk light tuna in water (four 5 oz cans / 452 g drained). Drain well and press the lid down on the can to squeeze out the last water, or the filling turns loose. Greek yogurt (2%, ½ cup / 113 g). Thick and plain. Nonfat works but tastes sharper; whole-milk tastes closest to mayonnaise. Seeded rye bread (8 slices / 256 g). About 32 g a slice, from a sliced deli-style loaf. We computed it as USDA's rye bread. Sharp cheddar (4 slices / 84 g). Sliced deli cheddar melts more evenly than shredded. Torn in half, one half goes under the filling and one over, so it glues both slices.

Recipe card

Tuna Melt on Rye with Greek Yogurt

Prep10min
Cook20min
Total30min
Serves4
Protein43g

Ingredients

Scales every quantity and the servings count. The panel stays per serving.

  • 45 oz cans low-sodium chunk light tuna in water (452 g drained)
  • ½ cup(113 g) 2% Greek yogurt
  • 2celery stalks (80 g), finely diced
  • ¼small red onion (30 g), finely diced
  • 1medium dill pickle (60 g), finely diced
  • 1 tbsp(15 g) Dijon mustard
  • 1 tbsp(15 ml) lemon juice
  • 2 tbsp(8 g) chopped fresh dill
  • ¼ tsp(0.5 g) black pepper
  • 8 slicesseeded rye bread (256 g)
  • 4 tsp(19 g) unsalted butter, softened
  • 4 slicessharp cheddar (84 g), torn in half
  • 1medium tomato (120 g), thinly sliced

Method

  1. Flake the tuna into a bowl with a fork. Add the yogurt, celery, onion, pickle, Dijon, lemon juice, dill and pepper and mix until evenly bound.

  2. Butter one side of each rye slice thinly, using all of the butter.

  3. Build 4 sandwiches, buttered sides out: rye, half a cheddar slice, a quarter of the tuna spread to the edges, tomato, half a cheddar slice, rye.

  4. Heat a 12-inch skillet over medium-low for 2 minutes. Add 2 sandwiches, cover and cook 4 to 5 minutes, until the bottoms are deep golden and the cheese starts to melt.

  5. Flip with a wide spatula, pressing gently. Cook uncovered 3 to 4 minutes more, until the second side is golden and the cheese runs at the edges.

  6. Repeat with the other 2 sandwiches. Rest 1 minute, then cut on the diagonal.

Cook’s note
Keep the heat at medium-low and the lid on for the first side: the filling goes in cold and thick, and gentle heat lets it warm through to the center in the time the rye takes to brown instead of burn.

Storage

The tuna salad keeps 3 days in the fridge. Griddled melts do not hold; build and cook them to order. Does not freeze.

Nutrition

Nutrition Facts
4 servings per recipeServing size 1 of 4 servings
Calories
per serving
455
% Daily Value*
Total Fat 15g19%
Saturated Fat 8g40%
Sodium 760mg33%
Total Carbohydrate 36g13%
Dietary Fiber 5g18%
Total Sugars 5g
Protein 43g86%

* The % Daily Value tells you how much a nutrient in a serving of food contributes to a daily diet. 2,000 calories a day is used for general nutrition advice.

How this panel was built

Every ingredient in this recipe is mapped to a USDA FoodData Central entry and the panel is computed from those entries for one serving as written. Optional ingredients and anything "to taste" are excluded. Values are rounded: protein to the gram, calories to the nearest 5 and sodium to the nearest 10 mg. The panel is calculated, not lab-tested; a different brand of stock or cheese will move sodium and fat. Cost per serving is an estimate at national-average store-brand prices; your store will differ.

How we count everything →

Protein per 100 kcal9.5 gSite median 8.0 g
Cost per 10 g protein$0.67Site median $0.82
Calories from protein38%4 kcal per gram
Made it? Rate this recipe
Course LunchMethod SkilletProtein source SeafoodCuisine American

Swaps and what they change

SwapPer serving
Leave out the dill pickle (60 g)−120 mg sodium · −$0.05
Regular chunk light tuna in water for low-sodium (same 4 cans)−35 kcal · −7 g protein · +220 mg sodium · −$0.20
Whole-wheat sandwich bread for rye (same 256 g)−5 kcal · +3 g protein · −90 mg sodium · −$0.19
Gruyère for cheddar (same 84 g)+1 g protein · +10 mg sodium · +$0.70
Add 2 hard-boiled large eggs (100 g), chopped, to the tuna salad+35 kcal · +3 g protein · +2.5 g fat · +40 mg sodium · +$0.09
Protein ladder

As written it is 43 g. Here is how to get to 50.

+3 g→ 46 g½ oz (14 g) more sharp cheddar per sandwich+55 kcal · +$0.19
+6 g→ 49 g1 hard-boiled large egg (50 g), chopped into each serving of filling+70 kcal · +$0.19
+12 g→ 55 g½ cup (113 g) 2% cottage cheese on the side, per plate+90 kcal · +$0.63
+14 g→ 57 g2 oz (56 g) more drained tuna per sandwich (a fifth and sixth can, split four ways)+65 kcal · +$0.70

The cottage cheese rung is the first that clears 50 g on its own (55 g).

What to serve with it
Same constraint: One pan
Uses what you already bought