A griddled tuna melt on seeded rye, the tuna salad bound with Greek yogurt and Dijon: 43 g protein and 455 calories.
A diner-style tuna melt griddled in a skillet: tuna salad bound with Greek yogurt and Dijon instead of mayonnaise, a slice of tomato, sharp cheddar on both sides of the filling, and seeded rye buttered thin on the outside and cooked until deep golden. The yogurt gives the salad the same creamy hold mayonnaise does and a little more tang, which the pickle, dill and lemon build on.
Thirty minutes in a 12-inch skillet with a lid, two sandwiches at a time. Buy chunk light tuna packed in water with no salt added; it is milder than albacore and holds together in larger flakes. A lid over the pan for the first side melts the cheese before the rye scorches. Seeded rye with caraway is the classic.
Ingredient notes
Low-sodium chunk light tuna in water (four 5 oz cans / 452 g drained). Drain well and press the lid down on the can to squeeze out the last water, or the filling turns loose. Greek yogurt (2%, ½ cup / 113 g). Thick and plain. Nonfat works but tastes sharper; whole-milk tastes closest to mayonnaise. Seeded rye bread (8 slices / 256 g). About 32 g a slice, from a sliced deli-style loaf. We computed it as USDA's rye bread. Sharp cheddar (4 slices / 84 g). Sliced deli cheddar melts more evenly than shredded. Torn in half, one half goes under the filling and one over, so it glues both slices.
Protein ladder
As written it is 43 g. Here is how to get to 50.
+3 g→ 46 g½ oz (14 g) more sharp cheddar per sandwich+55 kcal · +$0.19
+6 g→ 49 g1 hard-boiled large egg (50 g), chopped into each serving of filling+70 kcal · +$0.19
+12 g→ 55 g½ cup (113 g) 2% cottage cheese on the side, per plate+90 kcal · +$0.63
+14 g→ 57 g2 oz (56 g) more drained tuna per sandwich (a fifth and sixth can, split four ways)+65 kcal · +$0.70
The cottage cheese rung is the first that clears 50 g on its own (55 g).